Nanny Vs. Crèche – What’s Best For Your Baby?

Going back to work after maternity leave is tough enough… but have you thought about the pros and cons of crèche vs. nanny? Kate breaks it down…


Going back to work after maternity leave is hard enough without the added guilt of deciding what type of care is best for your baby. The options generally come down to two – nanny or crèche.

Leaving your small baby with anyone is a terrifying thought, so making the decision is seldom an easy one.

My son went to crèche when he was four months old, and although I couldn’t be happier with my decision, there are absolute pros and cons to both options.

If you are battling to make the choice, then hopefully the below will be of help to you.



  • Your child will be in an environment specifically catered to his or her needs.
  • The carers are trained in childcare and have all the skills needed to put your mind at ease.
  • The carers are not distracted by household chores such as cleaning and laundry.
  • There is no room for error and security precautions are of utmost importance.
  • Many crèches supply food and formula, which is a lifesaver for an already overworked parent.


  • Your baby will be exposed to more germs and will potentially get sicker quicker.
  • Operating hours are strictly enforced which means little room for error when it comes to traffic and late meetings.
  • They can be very pricey.
  • Some parents may worry about the carer/child ratio.
  • If your child falls ill and can’t go to crèche, you will need to have a backup plan in place.



  • Your baby will be looked after in your home, which means no uprooting or change of scenery.
  • A nanny can double up as a helper and can often assist with cleaning and cooking.
  • A live-in nanny means an on-call babysitter and allows you to have late meetings without worry (be prepared to pay extra for additional services that don’t fall within your nanny’s role).
  • A nanny provides a one-on-one experience and the bond between her and your baby can be extremely special.


  • A nanny might not have all the necessary skills to stimulate your baby, and may be distracted by household chores.
  • Your baby may not be as socialised as other crèche-going babies his or her age.
  • When your nanny goes on leave, you will need to have a backup plan in place.
  • If you require a live-in nanny, you will need to keep additional costs such in mind, including water, electricity and groceries.

At the end of the day, the decision you make will ultimately be the best one for your baby, and for you. Do your research, ask around and always trust your gut.

By Kate Kearney


Did you like this article? Then get more of the same from our weekly newsletter delivered to your inbox for FREE!

One thought on “Nanny Vs. Crèche – What’s Best For Your Baby?

  1. Good Day

    So i have 2 daughters aged 4years and 19months, My 4 year old started Nursery School at 18 months and it was the best decition i made with regard to her learning and development and also her social skills and her personality deveopled at that time. With my oldest when she was 8 months old i went back to work and she stayed with a day mother that had about 9 other babies and todlers as well as about 13 aftercare kids that came at 12pm and that for me was always a worry (how could one lady look after so many kids with no help) and drove my decition to put her into Nursery school at 18 months. My youngest however stayed with a family member that looked after just one other child who was 2years old and baby stayed with her from 4months old and that was so amazing because she had a friend and the day mother Bathed her in the morning and supplied all meals as well as supper for her and my 4year old. I made the decition to start my baby at the same nursery school her sister was at in january this year when she was 16months old and she has developed so much since shes been there… she is only 19months old and can count to 10 and speaks so well compared to many other non creche going babies.

    so i am pro creche but only when your baby is ready.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More from Kids: